When choosing between Oxbow and Science Selective for your pet’s skin and coat health, here’s what you need to know:
- Oxbow offers a Timothy hay-based supplement with flaxseed meal, chamomile, and sustainable palm oil. It targets inflammation and irritation, with Omega 3 and 6 fatty acids to promote healthy coats. It costs around $15.99 for a 4.2 oz container, making it cost-effective for long-term use. Best for pets with chronic skin issues or allergies.
- Science Selective provides heart-shaped treats made with linseed and spinach, rich in Omega fatty acids and Vitamin C for skin and fur health. These treats are priced between $6.80 and $10.10 for a 100 g pouch. Ideal for pets who enjoy treats and need additional Vitamin C.
Both are well-reviewed, with Oxbow rated 5.0/5 and Science Selective 4.9/5. Your choice depends on your pet’s preferences, dietary needs, and whether you prefer a supplement or treat format.
Oxbow vs Science Selective Pet Skin & Coat Supplement Comparison Chart
Oxbow Skin & Coat Care Products
What Oxbow Products Offer
Oxbow’s Natural Science Skin & Coat Support is designed to help reduce inflammation and promote healthy haircoats in small mammals, making it suitable for both herbivores like rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas, as well as omnivores such as rats, mice, hamsters, and gerbils. The product features a universal formulation with weight-based dosing to ensure accurate supplementation for different species.
The supplement is built on a Timothy grass base and includes key ingredients such as flaxseed meal (rich in omega fatty acids), chamomile (known for its anti-inflammatory properties), and sustainable palm oil (a source of antioxidants). Together, these components provide targeted nutritional support. The formula guarantees a minimum of 1.20% Omega 3 fatty acids and 1.40% Omega 6 fatty acids, while also offering crude fiber levels between 9.00% and 13.00% to support both skin health and digestive function.
"Natural Science Skin & Coat was formulated to help reduce inflammation and irritation of the skin and to aid in maintaining healthy haircoats in small mammals." – Dr. Cayla Iske, PhD, Oxbow Animal Health
The product is free from artificial colors and preservatives. Additionally, Oxbow uses RSPO– and Fair-Trade Certified palm oil, reflecting a commitment to sustainability. Customer feedback has been overwhelmingly positive, with the product holding a 5.0 out of 5 rating on Oxbow’s website, where 100% of reviewers recommend it.
Available Products and Sizes
Oxbow’s supplement is packaged in a 4.2 oz container priced at approximately $15.99. The tablets are uniform, making dosing straightforward and consistent.
Feeding guidelines are based on species and weight. For herbivores like rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas:
- 0-1 lb: 1/2 tablet daily
- 1-4 lb: 1 tablet daily
- Over 4 lb: 2 tablets daily
For smaller omnivores, dosing is tailored to their weight and species. It’s important to note that this supplement is not recommended for young, growing, pregnant, or lactating animals. For specific dosing or alternative administration methods, consulting a veterinarian is advised.
sbb-itb-e212914
Science Selective Skin & Coat Care Products
What Science Selective Products Offer
Science Selective has introduced heart-shaped treats designed for rabbits, guinea pigs, and chinchillas, specifically addressing issues like itchy skin, thinning fur, dryness, and dull coats. These treats are not only appealing to pets but also packed with nutrients that support skin and coat health.
The formula is built on a base of ground Timothy hay, providing 12% crude fiber to aid digestion and promote healthier skin. Two standout ingredients include 4% linseeds, which are packed with Omega 3 and 6 fatty acids to enhance coat shine and support the skin barrier, and 4% dried spinach, a natural source of Vitamin C, antioxidants, and iron. To further boost skin integrity and collagen production, the treats are fortified with 3,500 mg/kg of Vitamin C.
What’s more, the formula avoids artificial additives, ensuring a cleaner nutritional profile. The analytical composition highlights 8.0% crude protein and 2.0% crude fat, offering a balanced supplement for your pet’s diet.
Available Products and Sizes
The Skin & Coat Care Supplement comes in 100 g recyclable pouches, with prices typically ranging from $6.80 to $10.10, depending on the retailer. These heart-shaped treats are designed for hand-feeding, making it easy to bond with your pet while ensuring proper dosing. The recommended feeding guideline is 1–2 treats daily, alongside your pet’s regular diet. Always ensure fresh drinking water is available when introducing these supplements to your pet’s routine.
Comparing Ingredients: Oxbow vs. Science Selective
Ingredient Comparison Table
The table below highlights the key differences between Oxbow and Science Selective’s ingredients.
Oxbow uses a Timothy grass base, while Science Selective opts for an alfalfa meal base enriched with linseed, fennel, and dandelion, which serve as natural antioxidants. Both brands emphasize the use of natural components in their formulas.
For Omega fatty acids, Oxbow incorporates flaxseed meal, canola oil, and certified palm oil, delivering 1.20% Omega 3 and 1.40% Omega 6. On the other hand, Science Selective relies solely on linseed for its Omega content. Additionally, Oxbow includes 45 mg of chamomile and 13.5 mg of burdock root per tablet, which are known for their anti-inflammatory properties.
A notable difference is in sweeteners: Science Selective avoids added sugars, while Oxbow uses cane molasses in its formula. Science Selective also provides 800 mg/kg of Vitamin C, a feature absent in Oxbow’s supplement.
Nutritional Content Comparison
The ingredient variations result in distinct nutritional profiles. Oxbow’s supplement contains at least 12.00% crude protein, 6.00% crude fat, and 9.00%–13.00% crude fiber. Science Selective, by contrast, offers a higher 16.0% crude protein, 4.0% crude fat, and 15.0% crude fiber.
Oxbow’s higher fat content supports vitamin absorption and delivers concentrated Omega fatty acids, while Science Selective’s leaner formula is bolstered by its Vitamin C content. Both products feature comparable calcium levels – 0.40%–0.70% for Oxbow and approximately 0.6% for Science Selective – making them equally appropriate for adult small pets.
These differences in nutritional content provide a foundation for assessing how each product impacts skin and coat health.
How Well They Work: Results and Reviews
Results for Skin and Coat Health
Both Oxbow Natural Science Skin & Coat and Science Selective offer visible improvements in skin and coat health, but they take different approaches to achieve these results. Oxbow uses a combination of flaxseed meal, red palm oil, and canola oil to help reduce skin inflammation, provide lubrication, and promote a shiny, resilient coat. On the other hand, Science Selective relies on linseed as its primary omega source to support healthy skin and a glossy coat. These unique formulations cater to pets’ needs in their own ways.
Pet owners have reported noticeable benefits with both products. For instance, an Oxbow user in Chicago shared that their chinchilla’s recurring skin infections improved significantly with daily use. Similarly, Science Selective customers have observed changes like increased energy levels in their pets. One rabbit owner mentioned their pet was noticeably more energetic after just a month on the diet.
The way these products are used also differs. Oxbow’s hay-based tablets are designed as a daily supplement, while Science Selective integrates skin and coat support directly into its extruded nuggets. This means pet owners can choose between a standalone supplement or a complete food formula, depending on their preferences.
Customer Reviews and Ratings
Customer reviews highlight the effectiveness of both products. Science Selective Adult Rabbit Food has earned an impressive 4.9/5 rating from 17 reviews, while Oxbow Natural Science Skin & Coat Support boasts a perfect 5.0/5 rating on the manufacturer’s website, with every reviewer recommending it.
Taste and texture play a big role in customer feedback. Science Selective is often praised for its high palatability – many users note that their pets love the flavor and find the nuggets easy to digest. Oxbow, while generally well-accepted, has received occasional feedback about texture issues. For picky eaters, Oxbow suggests rolling the tablet in a warm, damp towel for a minute to enhance its natural aroma.
| Feature | Oxbow Natural Science Skin & Coat | Science Selective |
|---|---|---|
| Average Rating | 5.0/5 | 4.9/5 |
| Recommendation Rate | 100% | Not specified |
| Common Praise | Effective for chronic skin conditions, high-quality ingredients | High palatability, increased energy levels |
| Common Criticisms | Some texture/palatability issues reported | Limited review data available |
Price and Where to Buy
Price Per Ounce and Package Sizes
The pricing of these supplements is designed to be competitive while reflecting their quality and ingredients. Oxbow Natural Science Skin & Coat comes in 4.2-ounce packages, while Science Selective is sold in 3.5-ounce packages. At PetSmart, Oxbow is priced at $7.99 during sales or $9.79 at its regular price. This works out to about $1.90–$2.33 per ounce, with some budget-friendly options available for as low as $1.66 per ounce. Oxbow’s slightly larger package size offers better value, especially when purchased on sale or through discount retailers. These prices make both brands accessible while maintaining their reputation for quality.
Where to Buy These Products
You can find Oxbow and Science Selective products at major retailers like PetSmart, as well as online through platforms such as PetGuys.com and HeartyPet.com. For those who prefer local shopping, Oxbow’s Store Locator can help identify nearby independent pet stores and Preferred Retailers across the U.S. and Canada. Many of these local stores also offer special ordering if the product isn’t in stock.
PetSmart provides several convenient purchasing options, including in-store shopping, curbside pickup, same-day delivery via DoorDash, and an Autoship feature. The Autoship option not only ensures regular deliveries but may also come with discounts. Between these options, finding and purchasing these supplements is straightforward and flexible.
Main Differences and Which to Choose
Main Differences Between the Brands
When comparing Oxbow and Science Selective, one of the first things to note is the package size. Oxbow offers 4.2 oz per package, while Science Selective provides 3.5 oz. This means Oxbow gives you about 20% more product for a similar price, with a cost of approximately $1.90–$2.33 per ounce.
The ingredient profiles also differ. Oxbow uses a Timothy hay base enriched with herbs, offering anti-itch benefits and balanced omega fatty acids. On the other hand, Science Selective relies on linseed and soya oil for its fatty acid content. Additionally, Oxbow has a higher minimum crude fat level at 6.0%, compared to Science Selective’s 4.0%. These differences can help you decide which product suits your pet’s needs better.
Which Product to Choose
Here’s a quick guide based on the key differences:
- Choose Oxbow if your pet struggles with skin allergies or chronic itching. Its chamomile-infused formula can help reduce scratching and inflammation. Oxbow also stands out with clear dosing instructions for a wide range of small animals, from rabbits and guinea pigs to chinchillas, rats, mice, hamsters, and gerbils. Plus, the larger package size and lower per-ounce cost make it a practical choice for long-term use.
- Choose Science Selective if your pet’s diet works better with a pellet formulation. Keep in mind, though, that it comes in a smaller package and offers less detailed feeding guidance. Before starting any supplement, consult an exotics veterinarian, as skin issues could point to underlying problems like mites, hormonal imbalances, or infections. Also, remember that neither product is suitable for young, growing, pregnant, or nursing animals.
FAQs
How long until I see skin or coat changes?
Skin and coat changes usually become visible within 6 to 12 weeks of regular supplement use. That said, the timeline can differ based on your pet’s unique response and the particular supplement you choose.
Can I use these with my pet’s regular pellets or hay?
Yes, Oxbow and Science Selective products can be added to your pet’s regular pellets or hay, depending on their specific dietary needs. These products are designed to work alongside a balanced diet that includes hay and fresh vegetables – both crucial for maintaining your pet’s dental and digestive health. Just make sure the product you choose is appropriate for your pet’s species and age. If you’re unsure, it’s always a good idea to consult your veterinarian for advice.
What skin signs mean I should see a vet first?
If your pet starts showing signs such as excessive licking, scratching, hair loss, a foul odor, recurring infections, or skin inflammation and wounds, it’s time to consult a vet. These symptoms become even more worrisome if they persist or get worse over time.
